When this came out a few years back, the word on it was toxic. A lot of people were saying it was one of the “worst movies of the year”. Heck, there were even a couple who were tossing out a lot of “one of the worst movies of all time” talk. Bad movies are my specialty, so naturally this has been sitting in my queue for a while. It just took a while to get to it.
Matthew McConaughey stars as a surly boat captain who’s obsessed with hooking a big fish. His meager existence is shaken up when his ex-wife (Anne Hathaway) arrives on the scene offering him a proposition: Kill her loutish rich hubby (Jason Clarke) and walk away with a cool $10 million. He soon learns it isn’t that simple.
The set-up is promising and ripe with film noir possibilities. The small fishing village where everybody knows everything about everyone is an ideal location for such shenanigans too. Like many film noirs before it, there is a big twist, and I assume it was the twist that got everybody’s panties in a bunch. It’s the kind of thing where either you go with it, or you don’t. I can understand why some people wouldn’t take to it as it comes out of left field (even though there are several instances of foreshadowing leading up to the big reveal). I guess people that hate the twist hate the film on general principles. However, hating the entire thing just because of the twist is dismissive to the solid first hour or so that precedes it.
The cast is fine, with McConaughey in particular being outstanding as the drunken, hopeless fisherman. Hathaway is also very good as the battered wife and Clarke is despicable as her abusive husband. We also have strong supporting turns by Djimon Hounsou as McConaughey’s loyal first mate and Diane Lane as a local woman McConaughey provides stud service to.
So, does the twist work? Not really. It’s not that it’s “bad”, it just comes off a bit goofy. I was going to break it down in depth in this review, but I decided against it since it’s such a weird twist that you’re better off seeing it for yourself and drawing your own conclusions.
Overall, Serenity isn’t deserving of its reputation but it’s not exactly a misunderstood classic either. Without the twist, it would’ve been a good but forgettable thriller. With the twist it’s odd and ultimately unsuccessful one, but it remains an unforgettable slice of WTF cinema. Honestly, I think I’d prefer the latter.