The
best scene in John Milius’ Dillinger is the first one. Warren Oates, mean, scowling, and dangerous as
John Dillinger walks into a bank and approaches the teller window. The camera is positioned so that we are
seeing the teller’s point of view. He addresses
the audience in such a way that it feels like we are being held up
ourselves. It’s a startingly effective
sequence. Too bad the rest of the movie
never comes close to matching it.
From
there, Dillinger and his gang go around finding more banks to knock off. Along the way, he fancies a young woman (Michelle
Phillips from The Mamas and the Pappas) and romances her. Well, in the only way a guy like Dillinger
knows. Meanwhile, dogged G-Man Melvin
Purvis (a fine Ben Johnson) is on Dillinger’s trail, staying one step behind
him and his crew.
After
the gripping opening, the film soon falls into a repetitive pattern. After about the third shootout it gets to be a
bit numbing. Not only was Dillinger
meant to capitalize on the success of Bonnie and Clyde, it had to compete with
The Godfather too. That means the various
tommy gun deaths are long, drawn-out, and bloody. That doesn’t really make up for the lack of
story and engaging characters though.
Oates
softens up as he goes along, but it’s hard to sympathize with his character or
his romantic subplot. While Bonnie and
Clyde may have robbed banks, they were likeable folk hero outlaws. Oates, who is nevertheless very good in the
role, keeps the audience at arm’s length, which makes it difficult to get a
handle on him. The scenes with Johnson work
the best. He has a good gimmick of lighting
up a cigar before rubbing out a robber. It’s a small, but crucial touch that Dillinger’s
character doesn’t really have.
In
the end, none of it really gels. You
can, however, bide your time watching the colorful supporting cast do their
thing. Geoffrey Lewis and Harry Dean
Stanton make memorable impressions as members of Dillinger’s gang, and Richard
Dreyfuss pops up for a bit as Baby Face Nelson (who probably deserved his own
spin-off).