I’ve
liked every Mike Flanagan movie I’ve seen so far. Yes, that includes Ouija: Origin of Evil (mostly). I particularly enjoyed his Stephen King
adaptation, Gerald’s Game. When he was
announced as the director of Doctor Sleep, the sequel to King’s The Shining, I
thought he’d be the perfect choice. I
guess I was wrong.
Flanagan
excels when he’s given a small, claustrophobic setting. Oculus, Hush, and Gerald’s Game really show
what the man can do with a smallish budget and a single location. I think maybe Doctor Sleep was a little too
sprawling for him to handle as it takes place in multiple states, crisscrossing
around the country. He also uses a
multitude of special effects to show the use of the characters’ various extrasensory
powers. These range from hokey (like the
Peter Pan flying scenes) to mildly effective, but the spirit-eating sequences
just get too repetitive for their own good.
I
think the biggest problem is that Flanagan wants to serve two masters. He wants to appease the fickle King who
famously lambasted Stanley Kubrick’s 1980 version of his novel. He also wants to worship at the altar of Kubrick,
staging recreations of that film’s most iconic set pieces in almost a slavish
manner. Unfortunately, he never figures
out whose dick he wants to suck; King’s or Kubrick’s. Instead, he tries to service both cocks by going
back and forth. In doing so, all he
succeeds in doing is jerking the audience off for nearly three hours.
I
want to state for the record that there are flashes of what could’ve been. Ewan McGregor is excellent as the now-grown
Danny Torrance, the young survivor of the first film. The best scenes are of him sobering up and wrestling
with the metaphorical demons of his past.
(The worst ones are when he wrestles with them literally.)
The
stuff with the caravan of gypsy astral-projecting, soul-sucking psychic
vampires led by one of the members of 4 Non Blondes is… OK… I… guess? I mean King had FORTY YEARS to come up with a
sequel to The Shining and THIS is what he came up with? It’s like he waited to the last minute of his
deadline and wrote it on the car ride to his publisher like a kid turning in
his homework on Monday morning. Still,
Rebecca Ferguson has an odd energy about her that makes her character, Rose the
Hat a formidable villain.
The
film semi-works to a point. Once it goes
to The Overlook, it all goes downhill in cringe-inducing fashion. That’s mostly due to Flanagan’s need to
constantly remind viewers of how great The Shining was. I mean most of the final act feels like a
Parade of Homes version of The Overlook.
I mean there’s one scene where the elevators open up and the blood comes
cascading out, and a character walks by, sees it, and kinda shrugs like, “Oh
yeah. That,” and keeps walking.
What’s
worse are the recreations of Kubrick’s 1980 film. I know the de-aging CGI is a bit spotty
nowadays, but I would’ve gladly taken some video game-looking footage of Jack
Nicholson than the shit we get here. I
don’t want to spoil anything for you, but… HOOOOOOOOOOO BOY! Is it ever bad. Hell, I would’ve taken Steven Weber from the
fucking TV remake version of The Shining than the shit Flanagan hands us.
Fuck
it. Imma spoil it. Leave now before the spoiling starts. Okay, so when Danny goes into the Overlook
Bar, he runs face to face with the Bartender, who is no longer the character
Joe Turkel memorably played in the original, but… Jack Torrance. The problem is, the role of Jack Torrance is
one that very few people could fill, especially seeing as Jack Nicholson gave
one of the all-time great performances in the 1980 original. Instead of relying on CGI, or heck, letting Nicholson
essay the role playing his age, they went out and got… HENRY THOMAS. Elliott from E.T.? Let me tell you, on a short list of people to
inherit the role of Jack Torrance, Henry Thomas would be about my 675th
choice, right between Shaquille O’Neal and Steve Guttenberg.
Plus,
it doesn’t even make any fucking sense.
I mean, why would he be the bartender?
Yes, I know he’s just there to make Danny fall off the wagon by offering
him booze, but shouldn’t he really be THE CARETAKER? I mean, he’s ALWAYS been the caretaker, remember? Did they forget about that shit?
Is
it my fault? Am I holding the movie
version of The Shining in too high of a regard?
Maybe my expectations are too high.
Thinking anyone could ever come closing to matching the brilliance of
Kubrick is dumb of me, I know. In fact,
the stuff with the psychic vampires, bizarre as it is, was acceptable, mostly because,
at the very least, it was giving Danny a chance to pass the torch to the next
generation of Shiners while still allowing him to confront the trauma in his
past. However, tacking on a film student
version of The Shining with a community theater-level set of players while
trying to cram in shit that Kubrick (wisely) left out of King’s book doesn’t do
anyone any favors whatsoever. All it does is show (once again) that Kubrick
was right and King was wrong when it came to what should and should not be on
screen. The fact that Flanagan tries to
ape Kubrick so hard in the end just about singlehandedly derails the whole
movie. You also get a sense that no one
would’ve dared done this when Kubrick was alive. I mean, it’s one thing to wear grandma’s
jewelry after she’s dead. It’s another
thing to fuck her corpse.
It
kind of reminded me a little of another sequel to a great Kubrick classic,
2010. That movie is a lot of fun when it’s
doing its own thing and propelling the story forward. When it’s gratuitously playing homage to the
original, it just grinds to a fucking halt.
The only thing is, 2010 is a lot more entertaining than Doctor Sleep.
Another
problem is that there are just too many subplots that gum up the works. The shit with Danny getting sober and guiding
dying old folks through to the other side in a hospice center are just fine. The shit with the little psychic girl Abra
(Kyliegh Curran) playing detective aren’t bad either, although some of her
psychic shenanigans get to be a bit repetitive by the end. Rose is a memorably weird character, but she
gets way too much screen time, which ruins a bit of her mystery. We honestly didn’t need to know all the ins
and outs of her recruiting people to her ranks.
(They could’ve easily cut out all the shit with “Snakebite Andi’ and her
indoctrination into the tribe and not missed a single beat.)
I
can’t say I hated Doctor Sleep. Ewan’s
too good to completely dismiss it, even when it all turns to shit in the third
act. I just don’t thing I’ll be chopping
down the door to see it again.