Darlin’,
writer/director Pollyanna McIntosh’s sequel to the modern-day classic, The
Woman begins with The Woman (once again played by McIntosh) dumping her teenage
offspring, Darlin’ (Lauryn Canny) at the hospital in the middle of the night. The wild, animalistic girl is taken in by the
local Bishop (Bryan Batt) who places her in his Catholic school for wayward
young girls. The Bishop soon gets a
hairbrained scheme to reform Darlin’ and make her over as a proper lady to show
the world Jesus truly does save. (Not to
mention act as free publicity for his school.)
Let’s
just say, it does not go well.
Darlin’
is frustrating at times, as its uneven tone and pacing prevents it from really
taking flight. Much of that has to do
with the fact The Woman takes a backseat to her daughter for so much of the running
time. MacIntosh was such a force of
nature in the original that it’s a little dismaying to see her playing most of
the film from the sidelines. Occasionally,
she pops up now and then to remind you she’s still there (and to pad out the
body count a bit). These scenes don’t
add much to the movie, especially the subplot with her taking up with an army
of homeless women. Still it’s just nice
to see her covered from head to toe in muck again, even if she is relatively
subdued this time around.
The
character of Darlin’ more than makes up for whatever flaws the movie has. Canny totally creates a character you care
about and root for. It’s hard to see the
finale (which I wouldn’t dream of spoiling) as anything short of a tragedy as
(given her circumstances) Darlin’s prospects of either damnation or salvation
look equally horrifying (and disgusting).
Overall,
Darlin’ doesn’t come close to matching The Woman in terms of putting the
audience through the wringer. However,
it does something surprisingly different while remaining thematically similar
AND managing to keep the storyline from the original moving forward. That alone is some kind of a high-wire
act. It has a personality all its own,
while still feeling very much a part of its predecessor’s world. (There are stretches that feel like a horror
movie version of Lady Bird.)
I
also like how this is the second time the female lead of a Lucky McKee movie
went on to direct a sequel/remake of that film. MacIntosh follows in the footsteps of Angela Bettis
who directed the companion piece to McKee’s May, the underseen Roman. While her performance here isn’t as
revelatory as it was in The Woman, as a director, she shows so much promise
that I’m already looking forward to her next feature, whatever that may
be. Now, will someone please let Misty
Mundae direct a sequel to McKee’s Masters of Horror entry, Sick Girl so the
trilogy of actresses-directing-sequels-to-McKee-movies can be complete!