It’s always odd to me (READ: It makes me feel old) when people get nostalgic for shit I have absolutely no nostalgia for. Case in point: Y2K. The first scene has the main character using dial-up internet to chat on AOL Instant Messenger. I can honestly say I have no fondness for that shit, but you can tell the filmmakers are all rose-tinted glasses about it. Then again, the film takes place a quarter of a century ago, which for the key demographic will be most (or all) of their lifespans. So, what do I know?
The film follows a nerdy teen (Jaeden Martell from It) going to a New Year’s Eve party in 1999. You remember that day? When everyone thought all the computers were going to crash? Anyway, it turns out Y2K is real and at the stroke of midnight, all machines go haywire and start killing everyone. Everything from a Power Wheels car to a VCR to a blender becomes deadly. Eventually, the teenage survivors band together to stop the machines once and for all.
Basically, it’s kind of like a teen stoner comedy version of Maximum Overdrive.
Oh, and the girl our main character is obsessed with is that Rachel Zegler chick. You know, the one who tanked the Disney live-action remake genre for good? So, you can probably tell it’s not going to work out for him in the long run.
Y2K marks the directorial debut for SNL vet Kyle Mooney, who also plays a stoner video clerk. Mooney used to make filmed segments for the show, and this film kind of feels like a feature length version of one of his sketches. (The gratuitous celebrity cameo in the third act certainly feels like something you’d see an SNL musical guest do.) While it might’ve made for a good Grindhouse style trailer, it fumbles at feature length. The kills are admittedly amusing, but most everything else that holds it together is wafer thin. (The humanoid computer people look like something from that Five Nights at Freddy’s bullshit.)
It was produced by A24, but it honestly feels like anyone could’ve made it really. It doesn’t help that the movie features some of the worst music from the era played almost non-stop. I guess you could argue some choices were for ironic effect. I don’t know. A lot of it seemed pretty sincere to me.
Then again, I am not nostalgic for the era, so your mileage may vary. Let me put it to you this way: Martell’s character makes a mix CD. I made mixtapes back in my day. We are two entirely different animals from two different eras. I didn’t really mean to make this review a debate on whether my nostalgia is better than yours. It’s just that, without the crutch of late ‘90s nostalgia, Y2K falls flat on its face.