This is Spinal Tap is one of the quintessential cult comedies of all time. Not only is it one of the greatest Rock n’ Roll movies ever made, it (for better or worse) also kicked off the mockumentary style of comedy. It wasn’t really necessary for the original stars and director Rob Reiner to reunite after more than forty years for a sequel. Then again, for anyone who has seen the original more times than they can count, you’ll undoubtedly get a kick out of seeing the characters once again.
This time, director Marty DiBergi (Reiner) chronicles heavy metal gods Spinal Tap (Michael McKean, Christopher Guest, and Harry Shearer) as they prepare to do a reunion show in New Orleans. They haven’t seen each other, let alone played together, in fifteen years, so they have to get the rust off in the rehearsal studio. They must also find a new drummer since all their others have all died under mysterious circumstances.
The plot is wafer thin, not that it really needed one anyway. The best portion is the first act where we find out what the guys have been up to. Nigel (Guest) runs a cheese and guitar shop, David (McKean) writes music for when you’re on hold with customer service (“I won a Holdy!”), and Derek (Shearer) owns a glue museum. The movie sort of plateaus about halfway through as the scenes in the studio kind of go around in circles. The big concert finale is a lot of fun though and the ending is quite memorable.
Honestly, this might’ve worked better as a Netflix show or something akin to their 25th reunion special. That said, when it’s funny, it’s very funny, even if it never comes close to touching the original. For most fans (like me), just having everybody in the same room together and jamming will be enough. There isn’t much meat here, but there are plenty of laughs (and a couple of great cameos). For a forty years later sequel to a cult classic, it works better than it should… depending I guess on what you want out of it. Ultimately, it feels less like a continuation and more like a victory lap. Heck, most cult classics don’t even get that.