(DVR’ed from Showtime 2 on March 23, 2018 during a Showtime free preview weekend)
Back in the mid ‘90s, Stacy Title directed the star-studded cult flick The Last Supper. For whatever reason, she was never able to really capitalize on her early promise. Other than directing the dreadful Snoop Dogg’s Hood of Horrors, she hasn’t done a whole lot since. At least she was able to grind a paycheck out of this moderately entertaining, competent, but generic PG-13 horror flick.
College student Elliot (Douglas Smith) buys a house for dirt cheap and fixes it up with the help of his girlfriend (Cressida Bonas) and best bud (Lucien Laviscount). They soon learn it’s haunted by the sinister figure known as “The Bye Bye Man” (Doug Jones) who gets inside their heads and messes with their minds. Eventually, they can’t trust their own eyes as the Bye Bye Man puts images in their brains and tries to make them commit murder.
Even though this is all rather bloodless PG-13 horror stuff, Title tries her darnedest to keep you engaged. She uses a lot of camera movements and long takes to help put the audience in the character’s shoes. I’ll take that over a bunch of ill-advised jump scares any day. The green-tinged cinematography also helps to saturate the film in a deathly pall, even if they kind of go overboard with it at some junctures.
There is a kernel of an interesting idea here. If you say the Bye Bye Man’s name aloud to someone, they too will be driven insane by his visions. It’s a subtle metaphor for teenagers who are afraid to talk about their problems, and the more they keep it bottled up inside, the worse it becomes.
While it’s a potentially potent idea, the film is pretty much undone by the weak villain. I mean he’s just a tall pasty dude wearing a hoodie. Those guys are a dime a dozen. Jones has played some memorable monsters before, but unfortunately, this is not one of them.
Smith, Laviscount, and Bonas make for a solid trio. They’re certainly more likeable than most of their PG-13 horror movie counterparts, that’s for sure. We also get some extended cameos by name stars like Carrie-Anne Moss, Faye Dunaway, and Leigh Whannel, although they don’t really stick around for too long.
It’s Jenna (Terrifier) Kanell who makes the biggest impression as the sexy psychic who holds a séance at her friends’ housewarming party. You know, when you’re doing seances in your new home the first night you have company, you’re just asking for trouble. Next time maybe play Scattergories or something.