Pep
Squad is similar in many ways to Jawbreaker and Heathers as they are all about
teenagers resorting to kidnapping and murder to achieve popularity in high
school. The first and third acts work
the best as the various sociopathic and psychopathic girls vie for the title of
prom queen by murdering the competition. The second act, which revolves around some of
the teens kidnapping the child-molesting principal isn’t nearly as clever or funny. Not only does it bog the middle portion of
the movie down, it seems like it’s a part of an entirely different film altogether.
Pep
Squad works mostly as a showcase for Brooke Balderston who plays Cherry, the fiery
redheaded killer who literally throws people under the bus in order to be prom
queen. She’s really the only actress
that captures the tone that writer/director Steve Balderston (her brother) is
going for. Her campy, over-the-top
performance is easily the best thing about the film, and it only really comes
to life whenever she is front and center chewing the scenery and taking out the
competition.
Most
of the humor is sloppy and uneven, but there is some funny stuff here. The more random moments work the best (like
when the cheerleaders do a cheer to an El Camino). Unfortunately, there are just too many jokes
that land with a thud to consider Pep Squad a winner.
Balderston’s
style is sort of reminiscent of Mike Mendez, as he plays up the violence in a
campy, cartoonish, and outlandish way. It was filmed in 1998, a year before
Columbine, so I don’t know how the scenes of characters nonchalantly engaging
in drive-by shootings and mass murder at the school will play for some
viewers. Some may find them incredibly
tone-deaf, especially when school shootings seem to be the norm nowadays. Maybe Balderston was trying to tell us
something and we were just too stupid to listen.
AKA: I’ve Been Watching You 2: Prom Night.