HINDSIGHT IS 2020: THE WRETCHED (2020) *

Boy, talk about truth in advertising!  Finally, here’s a movie that lives up to its name!   

The Wretched was one of the biggest box office hits of 2020, topping the charts for six straight weeks!  That of course was because there was a pandemic going on and barely any movies were being released, but that just gives you an idea of what a shitty year it was for Hollywood, and the movies in general.  Even during a pandemic, I can’t imagine anyone venturing out and risking their lives to see this in a theater.  Heck, I saw it in the safety of my own home, and it was still hazardous to my health. 

A witch hitches a ride inside a deer carcass (?) and crawls out to find a new home living inside a woman (Zarah Mahler) who is renting a summer house.  Meanwhile, next door, a teenager named Ben (John-Paul Howard) is spending the summer with his recently divorced dad.  When his neighbor’s son comes to him for help, stating he no longer trusts his mom, Ben does what he can to protect him.  When the brat disappears, the witch comes after Ben.  Naturally, he tries to convince everyone she’s a witch and of course, no one believes him. 

The Wretched is a slow and disjointed movie filled with confounding “rules” and even worse logic.  The idea of a witch using a human host as a husk is intriguing.  However, the filmmakers drop the ball at every conceivable juncture. 

The big problem is the structure.  The scenes with Ben are basically a rip-off of Fright Night, right down to the scenes of him spying on his neighbor.  Even using that sturdy template, the directors, Brett and Drew T. Pierce manage to botch things.  It just highlights how well that classic was constructed and how lousy this one is put together.  Things plunge deeper into the toilet in the third act when the witch starts hopping from body to body.  I guess they were trying for vibe close to The Hidden, but in terms of quality it hews much closer to The Hidden 2.

The stuff with the neighbor lady being overtaken by the witch could’ve worked, and yet the film spends so much time on Ben’s shady past, girlfriend woes, etc. that she (nor the witch) have a chance to become a real character.  Instead, she’s merely a plot device.  Imagine if we actually cared about what happened to her.  It might not have saved the movie, but it might’ve given it a little weight.

It also doesn’t help that Howard makes for a thoroughly unlikeable lead.  He grates on your nerves so much that you actually start rooting for the witch.  Mahler isn’t bad as the witchy neighbor, but again, we don’t see enough of her to make much of a difference.  Even with the changes I suggested, there probably was no saving this one.  It’s just as wretched as the title implies.